Jump to: Upscale & Historic Dining | Casual Family Favorites | Seasonal & Specialty Spots | Know Before You Go | FAQs
New Braunfels may be famous for its German heritage and world-class BBQ, but the seafood scene is a hidden gem waiting to be explored. Whether you are craving a traditional Gulf Coast shrimp boil, fresh-shucked oysters, or a refined grilled salmon dinner, the options in this area cater to every palate and occasion.
Editor’s Note: We work hard to provide you with accurate, updated information. However, all details are subject to change. Please verify information before heading out. This post may contain affiliate links.
If you click and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend experiences we truly believe in!
Curious about how we choose our content? Here’s our process.
Also check out these articles – Best Steakhouse in New Braunfels, Ultimate Guide on Best Things To Do in New Braunfels, Best Seafood Restaurants in San Antonio, Romantic Restaurants New Braunfels, Best Sushi Restaurants in San Antonio, and Cheap Restaurants in New Braunfels.
Upscale & Historic Dining
McAdoo’s Seafood Co.
Image credit: McAdoo’s Seafood Company Facebook
Located in the meticulously restored 1915 Post Office, McAdoo’s offers a “Texas-Creole” menu that is widely considered the gold standard for seafood in New Braunfels.
Vibe Check: Sophisticated and historic. The high ceilings and original woodwork make it the ultimate date-night destination.
What to Order: The Atchafalaya—blackened catfish topped with crawfish etouffee.
Operating Hours: Sunday – Thursday 11 am – 9 pm | Friday – Saturday 11 am – 10 pm
Where: 196 N Castell Ave, New Braunfels, TX 78130
How Much: $$$ ($30 – $60 per person)
The Reel Seafood & Grill
The Reel is a contemporary spot that prides itself on sourcing the freshest catch directly from the Gulf. It offers a cleaner, more modern aesthetic compared to the historic spots downtown.
Vibe Check: Modern-casual. Great for business lunches or an upscale family dinner.
What to Order: The Blackened Redfish or their famous house fish tacos.
Operating Hours: Monday Closed | Tuesday – Saturday 11 am – 9 pm | Sunday 10 pm – 8 pm | Sunday Brunch 10 am – 1 pm
Where: 1683 West State Highway 46 #235, New Braunfels, TX 78132
How Much: $$$ ($25 – $45 per person)
Gristmill River Restaurant & Bar
While many go for the steak, the Gristmill’s seafood offerings are perfect for those dining in the historic Gruene district. The views of the Guadalupe River are unbeatable.
Vibe Check: Rustic, high-energy, and scenic.
What to Order: The Fresh Grilled Trout or the Bronze Catfish.
Operating Hours: Sunday – Thursday 11 am – 9 pm | Friday – Saturday 11 am – 10 pm
Where: 1287 Gruene Rd, New Braunfels, TX 78130
How Much: $$ ($20 – $40 per person)
Gruene River Grill
Image credit: Gruene River Grill Facebook
Gruene River Grill offers flavorful and hearty dishes, as well an intimate and cozy experience. If you’re craving for seafood, they serve up some fancy options.
Vibe Check: Rustic and cozy.
What to Order: Shrimp and Grits & Shrimp Wontons.
Operating Hours: Sunday – Thursday 11 am – 9 pm | Friday – Saturday 11 am – 10 pm
Where: 1259 Gruene Rd, New Braunfels, TX 78130
How Much: $$ ($15 – $30 per person)
Huisache Grill
Huisache Grill is a great place to hang out and have a tasty meal. Their patio area serves as a nice place to get some sun or enjoy the fire pit under the night sky. More than that, their extensive food and drink menu will give you a lot of options.
Vibe Check: Casual and bright with great outdoor areas.
What to Order: ‘303’ Seafood Salad and 4 Jumbo Bacon-Wrapped Shrimp.
Operating Hours: Monday Closed | Tuesday – Sunday 11 am – 10 pm
Where: 303 W San Antonio St, New Braunfels, TX 78130
How Much: $$$ ($25 – $50 per person)
Casual Family Favorites
Sea Island Shrimp House
Image credit: Sea Island Shrimp House Facebook
A South Texas legend since 1965, this is where locals go for consistent, high-quality fried seafood that won’t break the bank.
Vibe Check: Friendly, efficient, and great for kids.
What to Order: The “1965 Plate”—fried shrimp and a white fish fillet.
Operating Hours: Monday – Thursday 11 am – 9 pm | Friday – Saturday 11 am – 9:30 pm | Sunday 11 am – 8:30 pm
Where: 154 Creekside Crossing, New Braunfels, TX 78130
How Much: $$ ($15 – $25 per person)
Clear Springs Restaurant
Technically just a stone’s throw from New Braunfels, this former 1800s dance hall is famous for having some of the best fried catfish in the state of Texas.
Vibe Check: Classic Texas roadhouse with plenty of history.
What to Order: The World Famous Fried Catfish and a massive order of onion rings.
Operating Hours: Monday – Thursday 11 am – 9 pm | Friday – Saturday 11 am – 10 pm | Sunday 11 am – 9 pm
Where: 1692 TX-46, New Braunfels, TX 78132
How Much: $$ ($15 – $30 per person)
Red Lobster
While a national chain, this location is a staple for local families looking for reliable lobster tails and those iconic biscuits.
Vibe Check: Traditional sit-down seafood restaurant.
What to Order: The Ultimate Feast for a bit of everything.
Operating Hours: Sunday – Thursday 11 am – 10 pm | Friday – Saturday 11 am – 11 pm
Where: 4550 NW Loop 410 Centerview Callaghan, San Antonio, TX 78229
How Much: $$ ($20 – $45 per person)
Seasonal & Specialty Spots
Comal Crawfish
Image credit: Comal Crawfish Company Facebook
This is the premier spot for a “crawfish boil” atmosphere. It is seasonal, so it’s important to check their status before heading out.
Vibe Check: Backyard party. Picnic tables and plenty of paper towels.
What to Order: A 5lb bucket of crawfish with corn and sausage.
Operating Hours: Tuesday – Friday 5 pm – 9 pm | Saturday – Sunday 12 pm – 9 pm
Where: 311 FM306 #1B, New Braunfels, TX 78130
How Much: $$ ($20 – $40 per person – Market Price)
Mr. Crabby’s Seafood Kitchen & Bar
Just a short drive from New Braunfels, the Live Oak location of Mr. Crabby’s Seafood Kitchen & Bar is the premier place to go for seafood. From friend shrimp to seafood boils, they have delicious options. Pair that with sea-themed decor, and you’ll have a great time.
Vibe Check: Intimate and modern, with a casual feel.
What to Order: Fried Shrimp Basket and Shrimp Po’ Boy.
Operating Hours: Sunday – Thursday 11:30 am – 10 pm | Friday – Saturday 11:30 am – 11 pm
Where: 14601 I-35, Live Oak, TX 78233
How Much: $$ ($15 – $30 per person)
Know Before You Go
Most of these seafood spots are located within a 10-minute drive of Landa Park or the Comal River. During the peak summer tubing season (May – September), downtown spots like McAdoo’s and Gristmill will have significant wait times on weekends. We recommend using Yelp’s “Join Waitlist” feature whenever available!
Common Questions about Seafood Restaurants in New Braunfels
Are there any crab shacks in New Braunfels?
Yes! Comal Crawfish offers a classic boil experience with crab and crawfish, while McAdoo’s features a premium oyster and cold bar.
What restaurant is in the old post office in New Braunfels?
McAdoo’s Seafood Co. is famously housed in the restored historic Post Office building in downtown New Braunfels.
What is on the 1965 plate at Sea Island?
The 1965 plate includes their signature fried shrimp, a wild-caught fillet of white fish, and your choice of two sides.
Looking for more fun in the city? See the upcoming Weekend Events in San Antonio.
- 10 Best Tex Mex in San Antonio: Top Spots for Authentic Eats - April 26, 2026
- 10+ Best Restaurants in Boerne: Top Places to Eat (2026) - April 24, 2026
- 10 Best Earth Day Events San Antonio 2026 (Free & Family Friendly) - April 19, 2026
